Let’s make some delicious, heart-healthy carnivore ice cream. I converted this recipe from the insert that came with our ice cream churn, and it makes a full gallon, so it’s perfect for a family or for freezing in batches. It comes out rich and custardy, more like a classic custard-style ice cream than anything artificial.

What Makes This Carnivore Ice Cream Different

This is a real custard base built on eggs, milk, and heavy cream, preferably raw and grass-fed if you have access to it. The sweeteners are optional, and I’ll be upfront: once you add vanilla or a sweetener, this technically isn’t strict carnivore anymore, so adjust based on what your body needs and tolerates. If you want it fully carnivore, you can leave those out entirely.

Ingredients for Carnivore Ice Cream

This makes about a gallon:

  • 4 cups of milk, preferably raw and grass-fed
  • 4 cups of heavy cream, preferably raw
  • 9 whole eggs
  • A pinch of good salt (I use Redmond’s)
  • 2 to 3 teaspoons of good vanilla (optional)
  • 1/4 to 1/2 cup Allulose (optional, moves out the non-sugar sweetness — if you only use monk fruit it gets too bitter)
  • 20 to 25 drops of organic liquid monk fruit, to taste (optional)

How to Make Carnivore Ice Cream

  1. In a saucepan over medium heat, add 1 cup of the milk along with the Allulose and salt. Stir until the Allulose dissolves and bring it to a sweet, gentle simmer.
  2. In a blender (this works much better than mixing by hand), add all 9 eggs. Blend until fully combined — it should roughly double in volume.
  3. With the blender running on low, slowly pour in the hot milk mixture until fully blended.
  4. Add in the remaining cream and milk. If your blender isn’t big enough to hold everything, blend in as much as it will take and whisk the rest in by hand once it’s in the churn.
  5. Taste and adjust sweetness with the monk fruit, added last. Do not cook the monk fruit or add it to the hot milk — heat kills its sweetness, so it goes in only after everything has cooled.
  6. Pour everything into your ice cream churn, whisking in any remaining milk that didn’t fit in the blender.
  7. Churn according to your machine’s directions. Ours takes about 30 minutes and comes out like soft serve.

Tips for the Best Texture

Don’t stop the churn too soon. If you pull it before it’s fully done, the ice cream won’t expand to its full volume and you’ll end up with something denser and icier than you want. Keep the ice level high in your churn’s bucket the whole time it’s running, and let it go the full cycle for that proper soft-serve texture.

This carnivore ice cream has become a real treat in our house, and it’s so much better than anything with a long ingredient list from the store. Give it a try and let me know how it turns out for you.